Skip to main content

Post #10

Prompt: "What attitude does Dostoevsky create about Lebezyatnikov’s advanced social view? What is the tone? Contrast the tone with that afforded Luzhin. Why the difference? Although the novel is largely about great questions—sin, redemption, crime, punishment, and murder—much political and economic theory exists as well. What can you find in the text to constitute Dostoevsky’s attitudes towards capitalism and socialism? What is his preferred method?"

 Answer: Luzhin is quite narrow-minded, and thinks less of women than other characters. He really wants to marry a poor woman so that she can't escape. This is why she chose Dounia.  In contrast, Lebezyatnikov believes in the modern philosophies. Lebezyatnikov is also less self-centered, and wouldn't treat women the way old-styled Luzhin would.
I believe Dostoevsky believes in capitalism. One quote I found from Razumihin in part 3 chapter 5 saya: "Human nature is not taken into account, it is excluded, it's not supposed to exist! ... They believe that a social system that has come out of some mathematical brain is going to organize all humanity at once and make it just and sinless in an instant, quicker than any living process! ... The living soul demands life, the soul won't obey the rules of mechanics" I think because Dostoevesky decided to have Razumihin say this, he believes the same. They believe that human nature can not conform to numbers, like the way socialism would need it to.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Post #1

Prompt: "A complete summary of your novel. A well-written summary should be no more than one page, double-spaced, somewhere around 250 words. Do not quote the text, and do not paraphrase. You are summarizing. Remember, you need to write your summary in your OWN WORDS. I will be checking for plagiarism." Answer: Raskolnikov, a poor, suffering student begins plotting for an unknown crime. He goes to an old p awnbroker to try and trade a watch for money.Then, he goes to drink at a tavern, where he meets another poor, suffering man named Marmeladov. Marmeladov has run away from his family and has been drinking for days. Marmeladov shares his story, and  Raskolnikov goes to see his family. Later Raskolnikov gets an upsetting letter from his mom, and his family is coming to town soon to visit him. When at another tavern Raskolnikov hears someone talking bad about the pawnbroker, and decided it will be her who he will murder. When he is murdering her, her sister walks in and h...
Post a Comment
Read more

Post #7

Prompt: " Discuss the presentation of God and religion throughout the novel, and explain how the Epilogue contributes to this presentation. ALSO, explain how the Biblical story of Lazarus relates to Raskolnikov." Answer: In the novel, one of the major themes is suffering. Almost all, if not all, characters suffer in som way. Some do it to themselves. For Example,  Marmeladovmakes himself suffer with alcohol. He belives that he will be forgiven by God in the afterlife. In the novel sometimes people would suffer for religious reasons. For example, the painter turned himself in from committing the murder (even though he didn't do it) so that the suffering he would endure for turning himself in, would pay for other, lesser sins. Sonia aids Raskolnikov and is a crucial part of his redemption process. He redeems himself in the classic Christain way of admitting your sins, and asking forgiveness. Roskolnikov asked Sonia to read to him from The Bible that was given t...
Post a Comment
Read more